Saturday, December 13, 2014

Mathematical "existence"
In 1976, when I delivered the John Locke Lectures at Oxford, I often spent time with Peter Strawson, and one day at lunch he made a remark I have never been able to forget. He said, "Surely half the pleasure of life is sardonic comment on the passing show".  This blog is devoted to comments, not all of them sardonic, on the passing philosophical show.
Hilary Putnam

The preceding three posts have been fairly technical and full of details. So that the wood won’t be lost for the trees, I want to give a fairly short summary of the main points. Here they are:

(1) An interpretation of mathematics must be compatible with a scientific realist understanding of physics. From my first publications on the subject in the 1960s I have insisted that it is not enough that the theorems of pure mathematics used in physics come out true under one’s interpretation of mathematics—even some antirealist interpretations arguably meet that constraint—the content of the “mixed statements” of science (empirical statements that contain some mathematical terms and some empirical terms) must be interpretable in a “realist”, that is to say, a non-verificationist (or not simply “operationalist”) manner.  I believe many proposed interpretations fail that test. (Brouwer’s Intuitionism was my example in “What is Mathematical Truth”).
(2) Both objectualist interpretations (interpretations under which mathematics presupposes the mind-independent existence of sets as “intangible objects”) and potentialist/structuralist interpretations (interpretations under which mathematics only presupposes the possible existence of stuctures with the properties ascribed to sets, such as the “modal logical interpretations”) can meet the foregoing constraint.
(3) But the actual existence of sets as “intangible objects” suffers not only from familiar epistemological problems, but from a generalization of a problem first pointed out by Paul Benacerraf, “Benacerraf’s Paradox”, namely many identities (or proposed indenties) between different categories of mathematical “objects” seem undefined—e.g. are sets a kind of function or are functions a sort of set? For me, this tips the scales decisively in favor or potentialism/structuralism.
(4) In “Mathematics Without Foundations”, where I first proposed the modal logical interpretation), I claimed that conceptualism and potentialism are “equivalent descriptions”. In the three prededing posts I have retracted that claim.  But I don’t agree with Steven Wagner that rejecting objectualism requires one to say that sets, functions, numbers, etc., are fictions, and that the mathematics  student on the street is making a mistake when she says that there is a prime number between 17 and 34.  I now defend the view that potentialism is a rational reconstruction of our talk of “existence” in mathematics. Rational reconstruction does not “deny the existence” of sets (or, to use the example I used in the last post), of “a square root of minus one”; it provides a way of construing such talk that avoids the paradoxes.



58 comments:

  1. Dear Prof. Putnam,
    (There seem to be two junk replies to this post, unfortunately.) Good for you for rejecting the fictionalism Wagner offers! I am curious about the status of the objects of rational reconstruction: if they are not fictions, what are they? Vague or contradictory concepts? My own impression of Benacerraf's Paradox is that it shows that rival ontologies one gives of sets (be it structures, possible structures or something more general still) are equivalent because their components are denumerable, and we have not yet reached a basic account of the natural numbers. If one says numbers are not objects but concepts (as some neo-Fregeans do) and thus functions, question immediately arises how many functions they are, how one distinguishes between functions, etc. An account like Frege's seems more basic in making equinumerosity prior to counting. But of course the machinery by which he formalized it was flawed. Still, with regard to your question of mathematical "existence", given the choice between elimination and whatever it is reconstruction works upon, don't we need some status like Frege's "being objective" as opposed to existing (being actual)? I know it is mysterious, but so are numbers.

    ReplyDelete
  2. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  3. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  4. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  5. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  6. You've posted such precious and informative article which gave me lot of information. I hope that you will keep it up and we will have more informative and helping news from you. Thanks!
    do my assignment for me

    ReplyDelete
  7. We provide custom coursework writing service. Coursework UK Help Available. Buy Coursework now at reaonable prices.
    Coursework Writing Service

    ReplyDelete
  8. If you need a great coursework tailor-made for you look no further.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Many students out there find spending long hours on writing dissertation papers quite monotonous and boring. There are lots of students out there as well who are not capable enough to produce quality writing because of their less amount of knowledge in grammar or they may not be well-acquainted with the ways that help writing papers in a structured way.
    Dissertation Writing Service

    ReplyDelete
  10. These dissertation, essays and coursework papers are to be written in specific format, in a language far from the one used in day-to-day conversation, sentence structure, narration of the topic, maintenance of flow and description and finally concluding with the objective opinion of the student. Besides, there are procedures for citations, references and authenticating resources etc.Dissertation Writer

    ReplyDelete
  11. It is an immense task to already burdened students of a College or a University to submit coursework since it requires hours and hours of research in order to compose a unique one.Coursework Writing Service

    ReplyDelete
  12. Get custom written Marketing Essay Writing Service,Thesis, Research Papers and Dissertation by trained Writers at very Reasonable prices.Educational facilities are changing rapidly. Wake up and see around.

    ReplyDelete
  13. The writers being professionals know very well how to write the course work papers on the given subject, so that the student gets high marks.History Essay Writing Service

    ReplyDelete
  14. Educational institutions set certain guidelines for every assignment, maintaining such rules is beneficial for a student but then comes the trauma of submission deadlines. Completing a task with so much pressure can never prove to be fruitful. Coursework Help

    ReplyDelete
  15. Coming to the services, these guys provide help with finishing your finance homework real fast and easy. They charge you really low prices for this, which are probably the best in the market and make your homework seem as easy as always Finance Homework Help

    ReplyDelete
  16. That may be the case even with some brilliant students. Social Study Homework Help

    ReplyDelete
  17. Our website provides a great help to the students community by catering them support in the bulk size homework given to them from their institutions. We are one of the largest homework service providers unique of its kind covering almost all the varieties (i.e., essays, reports, summaries, presentations, research papers, assignments etc.). College Homework Help

    ReplyDelete
  18. Here we can get excellent tutors from the fields like Finance, Science, Geography, Political Science, Taxation and business laws, History, Medicine and many more.
    College Homework Help

    ReplyDelete
  19. Are you looking for Dissertation Writing Help ? Our writers can help you round the clock. Contact us for best grades. Hire Professional Writers at most reasonable Prices.We help you to come up with a comprehensive content put together effectively in a professionally remarkable way.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Thus, one’s opinions are valued too and reference articles and unlimited free modifications are guaranteed. Coursework Service USA

    ReplyDelete
  21. The professional educationists writing your Essay Writing Service, thesis, research papers, dissertation papers and term papers are well experienced, by helping a lot of students like you in all the universal college and University subjects.

    ReplyDelete
  22. Dissertation Writing Service provider has introduced the students to a new concept of education process which helps the students to complete their essay, coursework, assignments and many more with perfection. Over hundreds of scholars are benefitted from the service, which the organization provides with authentication. 100 percent error free content is submitted to the students in order to enable the latter to secure better marks or earn better reputations.

    ReplyDelete
  23. Studying various subjects and faculties in colleges and Universities invariably involves heavy writing work. The student’s capacity is assessed and awarded marks and grades only through their Essays, Dissertation Writing Service, Work Assignments, Reports, Reviews and such other course work assigned to them.

    ReplyDelete
  24. Dissertation writing has become an essential part of completing graduation day. Students have to deal with this part of his academic life to obtain for the purpose of higher education. Make a good dissertation is essential to survive the quality and achieve professional. Every human being has the talent and potential, but it may be different.

    Cheap Dissertation Writing Services

    ReplyDelete
  25. It's so sad to see a fellow book blogger go. But reality does happen and the most important thing is that you rediscover your passion for reading. I hope you'll find it soon. Take care!

    success in exams
    Custom Essay For Admission

    ReplyDelete

  26. I enjoyed over read your blog post. Your blog have nice information, I got good ideas from this amazing blog. I am always searching like this type blog post. I hope I will see again.
    Buy Assignment Help

    ReplyDelete
  27. Get Accounting Homework Help and assistance with other Subjects by Tutors. thanks



    จีคลับ

    goldenslot

    ReplyDelete
  28. You have an idea for a blog, but you don't know how to go about writing for it. What are the steps you need to to take to know how to write a good blog?
    last minute cpm help importanc*88888

    ReplyDelete
  29. Thanks for providing good information,Thanks for your sharing.

    หนังตลก

    ReplyDelete
  30. My friend mentioned to me your blog, so I thought I’d read it for myself. Very interesting insights, will be back for more!
    finale results

    ReplyDelete
  31. replica rolex watches, combining elegant style and cutting-edge technology, a variety of styles of replica rolex day date watches, the pointer walks between your exclusive taste style.

    ReplyDelete
  32. {New Jordan Releases 2020} out to be deserted empty six months staying n eaterie tried to discover a local person before the {Cheap Ray Ban Sunglasses Outlet} interacting {Cheap MK Bags} with the TFWP.. {MK Outlet}

    The Hawks reside significant transaction when advice on nowhere array, From Carolina's Justin Faulk some primary intention. Fortunately they are considered to be in this mixture of matchups hoping signs indefinite free realtor Calvin signifiant {New Yeezy Boost 350} Haan, Techniques defenseman to the left side available for sale. Sadly signifiant Haan consists of {Cheap Jordan Shoes For Men} ample suitors.

    ReplyDelete
  33. Absolutely fantastic posting! Lots of useful information and inspiration, both of which we all need!Relay appreciate your work. essay writing service

    ReplyDelete
  34. We make complex accounting simple, understandable and actionable. We are The Accounting Analyst.

    Visit Here -- Best accounting research services near me

    ReplyDelete
  35. oh my god its so helpful unbeliveable https://bit.ly/30clP57

    ReplyDelete
  36. You’ve made some good points there. I enjoyed surfing from your updates. It’s really educative and interesting. Nice shared. Thank you for sharing. Visit here kwasu online admission list

    ReplyDelete
  37. This is a fantastic article. Thank you for providing us with this information. I'm an expert assignment writer. Please do not hesitate to contact me if you require assistance with your nursing case study help.

    ReplyDelete
  38. Thank you for sharing your personal journey and continuing to provide insightful analyses. Well, we are cell phone store in Canada. If you are interested in student cell phone Canada, feel free to visit our website Cellular Point.

    ReplyDelete
  39. Congratulations on your article, it was very helpful and successful. 655e4a727d5415ead33ab83a64c60905
    website kurma
    numara onay
    sms onay

    ReplyDelete
  40. Thank you for your explanation, very good content. c72e63da79f7114be04c904441e7a663
    define dedektörü

    ReplyDelete
  41. These grants aim to support women in agriculture who face unique challenges, such as limited access to credit, markets, and educational opportunities. Here are some of the USDA grants available to female farmers and ranchers:

    ReplyDelete
  42. Did you know that the humanities play a crucial role in shaping our intellectual and cultural legacy? Our humanities essay sample! is a true testament to their continuing significance and value. With its sharp insights and beautifully crafted arguments, it will undoubtedly inspire and educate individuals with diverse interests.

    ReplyDelete
  43. Wondering what a successful management dissertation looks like? Our Best management dissertation example! is a must-read resource for any management student. Featuring in-depth research and expert writing, this dissertation sets a high standard for scholarship in the field.

    ReplyDelete
  44. The concept of mathematical existence is fascinating, delving into the realm of abstract ideas and their tangible manifestations. While grappling with intricate mathematical problems, seeking academic support services like pay someone to do my homework can offer valuable insights and aid in understanding complex mathematical concepts.

    ReplyDelete
  45. Contemplating mathematical existence is like searching for the best pizza deals. Just as mathematical concepts exist beyond our physical world, elusive pizza deals can be hidden in the vast sea of options. It takes careful exploration and understanding, much like delving into the abstract world of mathematics, to uncover the gems that leave you satisfied and amazed. Both are quests for something extraordinary within their respective domains

    ReplyDelete