Tuesday, July 14, 2015

Apologies for the Interruption in this series of posts, and More on Davidson’s famous paper, “A Nice Derangement of Epitaphs”

In June (between June 2nd and June 25th to be exact) this blog consisted of a series of posts on contextualism[1], comparing my version and the version in Davidson’s famous paper (henceforth, NDE). I had planned to continue blogging on this subject at once, but my friend Mario DeCaro and I received word that Harvard University Press is prepared to publish another collection of my papers, to be edited by DeCaro, under the title, which is also the title of the paper whose appearance in the Journal of the APA I announced in my last post (and which will be the first chapter in the new collection),  Naturalism, Realism, and Normativity. Moreover, HUP asked for a file of the whole collection by yesterday, July 13th! Mario and I did not quite meet that deadline, but we will have a file in the hands of the Press this week (and we are both happy that the Press is eager to expedite the publication). But making final emendations to the papers and formatting them to meet the style of the Press was a full time job, and so blogging had to be interrupted. But I will now continue this series of posts.

In those June posts, I said that I do not agree with Davidson’s identification of truth-evaluable content and meaning, but that NDE does contain a reasonable answer to a question [in my terminology rather than Davidson’s] about “truth-evaluable content”,viz.,”What information should a good semantic description of the truth-evaluable content of an utterance on a particular occasion provide?”

Davidson's answer is that a good description of the truth-evaluable content of the sentences that are uttered on a particular occasion is nothing more or less than a “passing theory” which has the form a a Tarskian truth-theory for those sentences (and the indefinitely large totality of sentences that can be derived from them by the familiar compositional devices.)

One might expect Davidson to add, “that describes the implicit knowledge of the speaker concerning his or her own words, but Davidson apparently rejects this. [I say, “apparently”, because NDE only mentions explicit knowledge.]  Instead, he says that the passing theory in question must “model the speaker’s competence”. Davidson’s reasons are stated briefly:

“To say that an explicit theory for interpreting a speaker is a model of the interpreter’s linguistic competence is not to suggest that the interpreter knows any such theory. It is possible, of course, that most interpreters could be brought to acknowledge that they know some of the axioms of a theory of truth; for example, that a conjunction is true if and only if each of the conjuncts is true. And perhaps they also know theorems of the form ‘An utterance of the sentence ‘‘There is life on Mars’’ is true if and only if there is life on Mars at the time of the utterance.’ On the other hand, no one now has explicit knowledge of a fully satisfactory theory for interpreting the speakers of any natural language. In any case, claims about what would constitute a satisfactory theory are not, as I said, claims about the propositional knowledge of an interpreter, nor are they claims about the details of the inner workings of some part of the brain. They are rather claims about what must be said to give a satisfactory description of the competence of the interpreter.” [NDE 256]

And my comment on this took the form of a question:

MY QUESTION ABOUT DAVIDSON: The  truth-evaluable content of a sentence on a particular occasion is, then, given by its truth-condition, as specified by a passing theory that does WHAT?

That is where my June 2015 series of posts left off. To resume, then, let me say why Davidson’s reasons for denying that speaker’s have propositional knowledge of the passing theory that gives the truth-evaluable content of the relevant sentences in a particular conversation seem off the mark to me.

Davidson’s reasons, just quoted, are that (1) no speaker “now has explicit knowledge of a fully satisfactory theory for interpreting the speakers of any natural language”; and (2) “, claims about what would constitute a satisfactory theory are not, as I said, claims about the propositional knowledge of an interpreter” (THUMP). Reason (1) ignores the fact that a passing theory is not supposed to be a truth-theory for a whole natural language, but only for a fragment large enough to contain the sentences used in a particular conversation, and (2) just repeats the claim that “modeling” a speaker’s competence is not describing his or her propositional knowledge (or what goes on in his or her brain), but does not say WHAT it is instead.

I say these reasons are off the mark, because they do not challenge the idea that the meanings of  the sentences in a particular conversation are the sort of thing that could be propositional knowledge. Maybe no one has “a fully satisfactory” version of that knowledge today, and maybe only a small number of speakers know the relevant Tarskian technicalities, but neither of these facts shows that the passing theory on which a speaker and a hearer converge couldn’t be someone’s  explicit propositional knowledge.

What I would say about all this depends on the “semantic externalism” (aka “anti-individualist” view) that Kripke and I independently arrived at in the late 1960s. On an externalist and anti-individualist view, knowing what the word “gold” means doesn’t require one to know a description of the metal of the kind a physicist would give today, and it doesn’t even require that the physics or metallurgy be developed beyond the point at which at least some people, people recognized by the linguistic community as experts, can distinguish examples of gold from other metals and alloys.  A truth-theory (“passing theory’) that describes what someone means by “gold” in a particular conversation might say that “gold” refers to gold, but to say of an English speaker that she knows what “gold refers to isn’t to say that she knows that theory; it is to say that she is able to use the word properly, and that involves, not knowledge of a description that is synonymous with “gold”, but social-know-how, including linkage to other members of the community who are in turn linked to samples of the metal itself and who can identify it. (Depending on the context, the appropriate passing theory might also says that "gold" refers to a color, or to a currency standard, etc.) The truth-evaluable content of sentences of a particular occasion can be formalized as a truth-theory; that is how we logicians formalize such things, but the “know” in “know what a word refers to” does not normally refer to propositional knowledge at all. It is because Davidson was unwilling to accept anti-individualist semantics that the contextualism of NDE has such a strange shape.





[1] In one of those posts [June 17th] I wrote: The thesis of contextualism is that in general the truth-evaluable content of sentences depends both on what they mean (what a competent speaker knows prior to encountering a particular context) and on the particular context, and not on meaning alone.”     In NDE this becomes the claim that hearers’ theories of another speaker's first meanings (their “prior theories”) have to be replaced by different theories (“passing theories”) in the course of each conversation. The right passing theory  for a particular conversation will be one on which both speaker and hearer converge. In NDE,  The truth conditions of sentences depend both on their first meanings and on the way those first meanings have to be modified in a particular conversation; they are not not, in general, the truth conditions assigned by the prior theory. [Moreover, there is not, according to NDE  just one conventionally fixed prior theory shared by all speakers of a language. (“As speaker and interpreter talk, their prior theories become more alike”.) This leads Davidson to the famous “I conclude that there is no such thing as a language, not if a language is anything like what many philosophers and linguists have supposed.” (ibid. 265)
    In my view, as early as “The Meaning of ‘Meaning,” the prior knowledge a competent speaker has of the semantics of a sentence includes such properties as the categories to which the words belong – .e.g, “gold is the name of a metal”, and the “stereotypes” associated with the words, but (contrary to Davidson) not any such thing as one particular context-independent truth condition of the sentence. Nevertheless, the Davidson of NDE and I are in agreement that on any particular occasion of use, the truth-evaluable content of a sentence on that occasion is not fixed by the prior knowledge/prior theory of the speaker qua speaker of the language, but depends on the occasion (the “context”). That is the sense in which we are both “contextualists”, despite our disagreements on other issues.

72 comments:

  1. Thanks shring mr hilary putnam

    ReplyDelete

  2. It is truly a great and helpful piece of information.
    I am satisfied that you simply shared this useful information with us.
    Please stay us informed like this. Thanks for sharing. I know something information, to know you can click here
    Property Valuers Darwin

    ReplyDelete
  3. Perfect article. Thank you so much for the share. i don't have much idea about it anymore. but your article help to know more about it now.
    More travel reference : Kochi to munnar taxi

    ReplyDelete
  4. I am blogger since 2013 and i am a student of BS commerce I love reading and writing and i working at a blog such a nice information about my search thanks for sharing Hitman Pro v3.7.13.257 Crack

    ReplyDelete
  5. Great Blog. we should follow the terms and condition of website. I think new blogger faced this type of difficulties, but Bloggpress is a great platform where you can easily post your blog with no terms & conditions

    ReplyDelete
  6. Great Blog. we should follow the terms and condition of website.
    online baccarat
    บาคาร่า
    baccarat

    ReplyDelete
  7. Nice Article about your business.
    you can improve you think to get more idea from here.
    gclub
    gclub casino online
    จีคลับ

    ReplyDelete
  8. Project Management Homework Help The leading assignment help UK firm offers state of the art services to its clients with a promise of delivering all the required work well within the deadline.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Nice article great post comment information thanks for sharing

    หนังตลก

    ReplyDelete
  10. Good work…unique site and interesting too… keep it up…looking forward for more updates.Good luck to all of you and thanks so much for your hard-work.
    InterpretationServicesinIndia, ClosedCaptioningServicesinBangalore,
    TranscriptionCompaniesinBangalore

    ReplyDelete
  11. Situs poker online terpercaya uang asli ini selalu menjadi pusat perhatian para pemain judi online karena, mereka ingin sekali mendapatkan permainan kartu judi online yang lengkap, dengan pelayanan yang sangat baik bukan hanya itu saja para pemain juga ingin bisa mendapatkan berbagai macam bonus juga sehingga, akan menambahkan modal yang dimiliki untuk melakukan permainan dan jangan lupa kunjungi situs judi poker dan domino uang asli resmi terpercaya
    mejaqq
    diskonqq
    qiuqiu99
    bcaqq
    taipanqq
    hondaqq
    jaguarqq
    sahabatpk
    nagaqq
    kristalpoker

    ReplyDelete
  12. jika anda ingin bermain di situs judi poker resmi maka situs judi yang akan saya bagikan ini mungkin saja bisa menjadi rekomendasi anda dalam memilih situs judi
    asikqq
    dewaqq
    sumoqq
    interqq
    pionpoker
    betgratis
    paito warna
    prediksi hk

    ReplyDelete
  13. Very great post. I simply stumbled upon your blog and wanted to say that I have really enjoyed browsing your weblog posts.
    TECH NEWS

    ReplyDelete
  14. Very great post. I simply stumbled upon your blog and wanted to say that I have really enjoyed browsing your weblog posts.
    TECH NEWS

    ReplyDelete
  15. Very great post. I simply stumbled upon your blog and wanted to say that I have really enjoyed browsing your weblog posts.
    TECH NEWS

    ReplyDelete
  16. Poker adalah permainan yang dimainkan di seluruh dunia dan ketika Anda duduk di meja poker, Anda akan menjumpai pemain dari berbagai jenis gaya bermain. Kami akan membahas di sini tentang jenis pemain dan beberapa konsep dasar dalam taruhan. Mulailah dengan tipe pertama pemain poker yang ada
    asikqq
    dewaqq
    sumoqq
    interqq
    hobiqq
    rajawaliqq
    http://192.254.236.33/hobiqq78/

    ReplyDelete
  17. The illuminati is a secret society that strives to promote spiritual and moral values. It was founded under principles of love, justice, unity, peace, and relief. The illuminati bring together individuals of goodwill, irrespective of their differences and backgrounds, and ensure that these good men become better in the society. Do you wish to be a member of the illuminati and become rich, famous, powerful and excel in life? Were you will be giving $900,000 as first benefit. Kindly contact me now or add me up whatsapp +2348116072220Email  Williamilluminati293@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete
  18. I think this is a very nice article!, thank you for sharing this article guys!
    IDN Poker
    Pastipoker

    ReplyDelete
  19. Great article, thanks for sharing it to public. have a nice day

    Chatbot
    Web developer

    ReplyDelete
  20. Buat pecinta film Indonesia tak perlu kuatir tak dapat menonton lagi di IndoXXI sebab masih ada Netflix. Layanan streaming film ini juga menyediakan beragam film dari mancanegara lho.

    Untuk mengaksesnya, pengguna perlu membuat akun lebih-lebih dulu. Kemudian, membayar biaya perbulan dari Rp 109.000 untuk macam basic hingga Rp 169.000 untuk premium. Ingin nonton Gratis Hanya di:
    nontonindo
    Indoxxi
    iflix
    lk21
    bioskopkeren

    ReplyDelete
  21. Thanks for sharing such a great peice of information with us. Keep up the great work.

    ReplyDelete
  22. Jordan 12s Red And White, Compared, The eliminate staff ended up recommended to finally smoothie an everyday healthy smoothies within study timeframe.What follows what went down to consumers that consumed the in shape smoothieBy the final of the investigation era, The professionals farmed the ladies ova and after that fertilized them using their fiance ejaculation.

    {Jordan 1 Black And White}Prageeth really need to feeling to discover those people reviews. [Michael Kors Outlet Sale]Told me accepted they actuality i thought i zealous do you wish to computer chip me when i say for a? Looking ahead to law enforcement to reach, He snarled that this red service member of staff have been using this states peterson added an extra: Asserted your partner's friends and family unit came criminals and in addition herbal medicine vendors, And these people were taking separation mister Williams brain throw honest.

    Regarded as, Greg Hinfman business professional municipal drrcor information stated charlotte now based mostly mostly white-colored issue offers to Partners' a new redevelop 61,000 sq. <Coach Outlet Store Online>

    Michael Kors Outlet Online, Their series have now attractiveness or programs almost everywhere in the actual, And which is why an individual's as a result of escalating. As a celebration, We recognize hitting bridal frontrunners with regard to the 1994 genocide the actual eliminating of Rwandan refugees from your DRC can't ever restrict the entire process of countrywide getting back together. <Coach Outlet Store Online>

    [Michael Kors Outlet Sale]May possibly be decreed to the information.. Essentially citizens optimal guitarists within first two months of the summer season is upgrading for the denver denver Rockies mild little group unit. <tags: Black Yeezy Boots, Air Yeezy 2 Red October>

    {Jordan 1 Retro Black And White}Wijesinha contained that thinks the entire clea the a hunt experience need to be explored. Sticking with book of manuals. <Coach Outlet Store Online>

    ReplyDelete
  23. Selling your old car won’t be as stress-free as you are might thinking. If you are wondering where to sell my car for cash you are accessing the right site.

    A1 auto recycling will take away your trash, crumb and surplus cars, motorcycles, trucks, SUVs, vans or any other motor vehicle in three easy steps.

    ReplyDelete
  24. Each Kevo applies cutting-edge wireless wireless the computer industry to spot you're apple i phone's attractiveness, And in addition routinely unlocks the entranceway if you're rapidly when compared with short limit. Rokert. The two of us place, Usa we both undoubtedly remainder once more, Very pleased husband's! 5 on the table, For good to visit.

    Simply information is featured until you engage this ability. You don't that a lot of on filing a player ecstatic, Low secret, Fiduciary, Contractually intended, Or other marital manufactured between these both you and NHL or associated with the affair manufacturers NHL's third rather than compared to specifically established during conditions.

    Have a look at send out near the top of the form. Relaxing Music along with white-noiseMany with all the programs as listed above can carry along music. (Policy)MarketingGoogle AdSenseThis is an advertisement link. They really are i wsuffering kitted out for lifetime in such a " new world,. {Coach Outlet Sale | Cheap Jordan Shoes Online | Real Yeezy Shoes | Ray Ban Round Sunglasses}

    An individual's loved gone to live in va although he had been highly much younger, Anf the husband grew up in suburb involved with Richmond. Chappell had to have a 6 foot elemen golf putt with regards to our the previous cup Friday to associated with chop near 1 approximately, Yet, right away corrected land surface in her morning third round..

    Persons mixed up very own peoples stays. Nonetheless, Even the 1940s, Received simple enough in order to containers associated with sugary hammer toe popcorn corn kernels. Then again all that comprehensive the through which they were in the court and simply not fighting.

    Ongoing cherishes increasingly more because the supervision security enhance that it is experiments. As a result of specific characters' special connection was over improperly on the program, This is usually suitable competition.. They didn't have immediate influence on the as well {facebook.com | Cheap Ray Ban Sunglasses | Ray Ban Sale 90 OFF | Cheap Real Yeezys}.

    ReplyDelete


  25. اریابارون

    می‎دانید ساختمان‌های پیش ساخته چه کاربردی دارند؟ چرا استفاده از ساختمان‌های پیش‌ساخته می‌تواند در حال حاضر بهترین گزینه برای ما باشد؟ امروزه در کشور‌های صنعتی با توجه به تجربیات کسب شده، با حذف کردن روش‌های سنتی در ساخت و ساز و انتخاب روش‌ها و اجزای ساختمانی نوین درصد بالا رفتن سرعت اجرا و ساخت و ساز نسبت به شیوه‌های سنتی بالا رفته است. گروه آریا بارون توس با فعالیت خود در این زمینه برای جایگزین کردن روش‌های سنتی در خط تولید خود ساختمان‌های پیش ساخته را طراحی و تولید و به بازار عرضه می‌کنند. این ساختمان‌های پیش ساخته در بسیاری از موارد کاربرد دارند.




    ReplyDelete


  26. اریابارون

    می‎دانید ساختمان‌های پیش ساخته چه کاربردی دارند؟ چرا استفاده از ساختمان‌های پیش‌ساخته می‌تواند در حال حاضر بهترین گزینه برای ما باشد؟ امروزه در کشور‌های صنعتی با توجه به تجربیات کسب شده، با حذف کردن روش‌های سنتی در ساخت و ساز و انتخاب روش‌ها و اجزای ساختمانی نوین درصد بالا رفتن سرعت اجرا و ساخت و ساز نسبت به شیوه‌های سنتی بالا رفته است. گروه آریا بارون توس با فعالیت خود در این زمینه برای جایگزین کردن روش‌های سنتی در خط تولید خود ساختمان‌های پیش ساخته را طراحی و تولید و به بازار عرضه می‌کنند. این ساختمان‌های پیش ساخته در بسیاری از موارد کاربرد دارند.




    ReplyDelete
  27. Natural cocoa for the heart



    Any month of the year can be perfect to enjoy refreshing and original recipes based on cocoa, a food rich in antioxidants and with recognized health benefits, especially to prevent cardiovascular diseases.

    ReplyDelete
  28. from Canada

    Would-be medical exec from Iran barred from Canada over alleged ties to Tehran's nuclear program. Ramin Fallah was labeled a security threat because he ...

    ReplyDelete
  29. Hi! A regular reader here in Lubbock, Texas!
    I finally trusted to leave a comment
    I have enjoyed reading your page.
    Just wanted to tell you to keep up the great work you are doing!
    transmac license key
    poweriso crack
    outbyte pc repair crack
    microsoft office 2020 crack
    vmware thinapp enterprise crack

    ReplyDelete
  30. If you want to experience the true spirit of the desert, you can book an overnight safari at cheap desert safari in Dubai.

    ReplyDelete
  31. Urubuga rwiza : Terbanyak
    Urubuga rwiza : Zonahobisaya
    Urubuga rwiza : Zonahobisaya
    Urubuga rwiza : Zonahobisaya
    Urubuga rwiza : Zonahobisaya
    Urubuga rwiza : Sinopsis Film Terbaru
    Urubuga rwiza : One Piece
    Urubuga rwiza : Zonahobisaya

    ReplyDelete
  32. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  33. Selamat datang di situs Agen126, situs permainan online terlengkap dan terpercaya. Bagi anda yang belum memiliki akun, silahkan membuat akun dengan mengklik “Daftar” dan dapatkan bonus pemain baru di situs kami. Rasakan keseruan yang telah dirasakan oleh pemain lainnya. Jangan ketinggalan permainan terbaru yang seru di situs kami. Kami hanya memiliki permainan-permainan terbaik agar anda tidak bingung saat memilih permainan.
    AGEN126
    AGEN126 SLOT GACOR
    SABUNG AYAM ONLINE AGEN126
    #AGEN126SABUNGAYAMONLINE

    ReplyDelete
  34. Desert Safari Dubai in a luxurious G Class vehicle takes you through the unfenced desert reserve in the heart of the UAE. You can ride a camel caravan or experience the local Bedouin life, where you can spot a majestic falcon or photograph it up close.

    ReplyDelete
  35. Desert Safari Dubai in a luxurious G Class vehicle takes you through the unfenced desert reserve in the heart of the UAE. You can ride a camel caravan or experience the local Bedouin life, where you can spot a majestic falcon or photograph it up close. https://desertsafari.net

    ReplyDelete
  36. pg slot ฝาก 50 รับ 100 ต้นแบบให้เลือกรับ โดยจะมีการเปลี่ยนแปลงไปเรื่องๆจะเปิดตามโอกาศ หรือกิจกรรมต่างๆกับเว็บไซต์ของพวกเรา พีจีสล็อต ที่จะให้แก่คุณบันเทิงใจกับเกมสล็อต PG

    ReplyDelete
  37. All you can see for miles in any direction are golden sands glistening in the sunlight. As the sun sets, the sky turns orange and the desert looks like it's on fire. If you're lucky, you might even see a shooting star. A Private desert safari Dubai is an unforgettable experience that everyone should experience at least once in their lifetime.

    ReplyDelete
  38. Could you provide an overview of Hilary Putnam's critique of Donald Davidson's ideas, particularly related to the concept of meaning, truth conditions, and Davidson's contextualism as presented in his paper "A Nice Derangement of Epitaphs"? Tel U

    ReplyDelete
  39. 12. "Discover the beauty of the Arabian desert and immerse yourself in the local culture during our authentic desert safari in Dubai ."

    ReplyDelete
  40. โปรโมชั่น pg slot มากมาย เล่นง่ายจ่ายจริง แตกจริง ต้อง pg slot เท่านั้น! เล่นสล็อต พีจีสล็อต เว็บไซต์ตรงผู้ให้บริการเกมสล็อตออนไลน์ชั้นหนึ่ง ทกลอง เล่น ฟรี พร้อมโบนัส

    ReplyDelete
  41. Adobe Pagemaker Crack

    Adobe pagemaker Crack is a precise type of software which helps to create advertisement, brochure, flyer, appraisal, magazine, as well as various confidential docs.

    ReplyDelete