Tuesday, July 28, 2015

Further remarks about Davidson

What I have said so far, in essence, is that although “A Nice Derangement” of Epitaphs did mark a radical change in some of Davidson’s views (the most famous change being his denial that there are “languages” as philosophers think of languages, namely as requiring conventions shared by a linguistic community that determine the meanings of the sentences), the central doctrine of Davidsonianism remains fixed, namely that the way to think of meanings (of sentences, again – why ‘sentences’ and not words is something I explain at the end of this post) is to think of them as truth conditions generated by a Tarski-style semantic theory. But in NDE the semantic theory is no longer held to be valid for a whole community, or even for an individual speaker: there is now a semantic theory that an individual speaker assumes when she begins to talk to another member of the community (her “prior theory”) and a theory that the speaker and the hearer ideally converge on in the course of a particular conversation or on a particular occasion (their “passing theory”). Thus Davidson became a “contextualist” (his semantics became “occasion sensitive”, in my terminology), but semantics was still a là Tarski.

I said in the previous post that I didn’t agree with Davidson that meanings should be identified with truth-conditions. I agreed, however, that truth-conditions are occasion-sensitive (so Davidson would be right that meanings are equally occasion sensitive if meanings were truth conditions). But I won't repeat all that.

I also argued that Davidson does not really say in what sense a particular speaker’s competence is “modeled” by a passing theory. He only emphasized that it is not known by the speaker.

But let us go a little farther.  For me the main locus of occasion sensitivity, as I explained in my June 2nd post [“Occasion-sensitivity and productivity are not incompatible”] is the reference of names and predicates. Sentences,”E.g., there is milk on the table” have occasion sensitive truth-conditions because the words they contain have different references; e.g.,  a little spilled  milk may or may not count as “milk” for the purpose of evaluating the truth or falsity of “there is milk on the table” on a particular occasion.

Davidson, however, endorsed Quine’s unfortunate doctrine of the indeterminacy of reference.. That is why Davidson says so little about the semantics of individual words; words like "pig", "blue", "home", "coffee" are primary referring expressions in English, for example. And reference is not a dubious metaphysical notion, as Quine thought. Give me that, and it is not hard to say something (of course, not everything) about what a passing theory has to do to “model a speaker’s competence"): it has to tell us what his or her words referred to on the relevant occasion.
   (to be continued)


  1. I certainly have a lot of reading to do...

  2. We stumbled ovver here from a different website aand thought I might as well check things out.

    I like what I see so now i amm following you.
    Look forward to finding out about your web page again.

  3. This comment has been removed by the author.

  4. very nice
    <a href="https://www.lasergames.ma/ </a>

  5. Cosplay Beautiful Girl #1


    Cosplay Beautiful Girl #2


    Cosplay Beautiful Girl #3


    Cosplay Beautiful Girl #4


    Cosplay Beautiful Girl #5


    Cosplay Beautiful Girl #6


    The secret love of brother and sister


    Two cute sisters share boyfriend


    Young girl with natural beauty


    Beautiful young teacher with sexy breasts


    Young girl 's father attacked her husband


    Beautiful young girl with sexy body


    Beautiful young stepmother with son's friend


    biet thu Brg Coastal City


    Bat Dong san nOi bat


  6. Nice Article about your business.
    you can improve you think to get more idea from here Online Invoicing

  7. Please Click Here this post
    Please Welcome to Casino online All Games
    Wish all u Good Luck
    Thanks You!!!

    gclub casino

  8. Good post, thanks for sharing it with us, hope to see more such posts from you!

  9. i really likes your blog and You have shared the whole concept really well. and Very beautifully soulful read! thanks for sharing.
    GCLUB มือถือ

  10. MedicalTheses.Com Good way of telling, good post to take facts regarding my presentation subject matter, which i am going to deliver in my college

  11. PaymeToDoHomework.Com I personally like your post, you have shared good article. It will help me in great deal.

  12. Very helpful suggestions that help in the optimizing website. thank for sharing the link.